http://www.rploscabos.com/mexico-travel-safety-2009/
mexico travel safety 2009
mexico travel safety 2009
Safety, Violence, Drugs, And Other Reasons To Vacation In Oaxaca, Mexico
Alvin Starkman M.A., LL.B.
Five articles on page A3 of a daily newspaper began as follows:
- The special investigations unit has been called in after a man was shot and a second man broke his jaw during an arrest…
- A woman described as armed and dangerous is wanted by police in a home invasion robbery…
- A man barricaded himself inside a house for almost an hour after attacking another man with an axe…
- A man tried to lure a 14-year-old into his truck…
- A young man is clinging to life after being shot in the head at a west-end community centre during a brazen afternoon shooting…
From June through December, 2006, and in fact well into 2007, foreign governments issued initially travel advisories, then outright advice against traveling to Oaxaca because of purported rampant violence and safety concerns, and again more recently warnings about civil unrest and violence in this southern Mexico city of about 400,000, a mecca for tourists. Yet New York, Chicago, L.A. and Toronto remained immune from such government wrath…oddly so given that while residents in large Canadian and American cities are regularly subjected to street violence, no tourist was targeted or injured during months of Oaxacan unrest.
The excerpts from the City Page referenced above are not from a Oaxaca newspaper, but rather from The Toronto Star, April 8, 2007, in the midst of arguably one of the most tranquil and peaceful family weekends of the year, Easter.
There are many opinions as to why false and misleading information is disseminated about occurrences in Third World countries, and in this case Mexico (more specifically Oaxaca), while fact based reports from First World countries in the Western Hemisphere, take Canada for example, do not result in, for one thing, government advisories.
Western governments have a history of paternalistic attitudes towards their citizens dating to the period of colonization. It continues to date. Perhaps more importantly, during the 20th century civil liability has become a concern, more so in the US than in Canada in terms of claims for monetary damages arising out of allegations of negligence perpetrated by governments against citizens: “You had information about civil unrest and the possibility of injury, so why didn’t you warn me against traveling to Oaxaca?”
What is a Western consul, resident in Oaxaca, to do or recommend to his or her principals in Mexico City, Washington or Ottawa? Especially when local and international media, each with its own agenda, report incidents of unrest and at times violence? Does governmental due diligence include checking the veracity of reports of targeting or injury to tourists, and when there are no such reports, ought they include some such reference to their findings in their warnings? Should this writer have not stated that no tourist was injured, when in fact there was a report of a tourist who elected to walk alongside a march with his video camera, apparently inadvertently receiving a bit of mace or pepper spray in his face, then smiling and laughing it off when questioned by reporters? Should we demand more particulars from our governments upon which we are expected to rely? Should we perhaps request comparative statistical data when advisories are issued, regarding injury to innocents in Canadian and American cities of comparable size to that of Oaxaca?
Mexico, with different legal and political systems both historically and in contemporary times, would appear to have a different attitude towards protecting its citizenry traveling abroad, at least to Canada and the US, and certainly the federal government does not appear to have the same legal liability concerns, not having developed a British common law system which gives residents significant rights regarding claims of negligence.
Perhaps the Mexican government should begin to issue travel advisories based upon reviewing newspapers, wire service and internet reports, and first hand accounts of violence against citizens of Western cities:
“Violence erupted against innocent people, some of whom may have been Mexican tourists, in at least five separate incidents over Easter weekend in Toronto. We urge our citizens to exercise extreme caution should they dare to maintain their existing travel plans to that part of Canada.”
While arguably misleading, at least the facts would be accurately stated. We would then see how much pressure would be brought to bear by Canada, and how fast, upon Mexico to retract its warning. The Mexican government would then have received a good lesson on how to use diplomacy to convince foreign governments to be more detailed, accurate and cautious in issuing advisories.
Before the critics and skeptics jump on the obvious gap in reasoning and fallaciousness of the analogy, they ought to research whether or not the Mexican government issued travel advisories regarding Toronto, Ontario or Canada, in the face of the two incidents bearing the closest similarity in recent memory to the Oaxacan unrest…the Oka reserve uprising and the Dudley George killing with associated conflict.
The foregoing should not be relied upon by anyone considering traveling outside of his or her home country, and the article’s intent is not to influence anyone’s travel plans nor to opine regarding any government laws, rules, regulations, policies or procedures.
*Author’s update: Since the foregoing article contains historical information, I’ve taken the liberty of examining more recent news pages, the front page of the same Toronto Star, online version, for the Greater Toronto Area, from May 28 and May 31, 2009, and for April 17, 2010. Dare to compare with headlines from mainstream Oaxaca media? Consider the following:
May 28, 2009:
- “Teen guilty in rugby death”
- “Body of missing teen found in Toronto harbour” [he had been in an argument the night he went missing, so accidental drowning is not suspecte]
- “New Tori murder charge” ["An 18-year-old woman charged in the disappearance of eight-year-old Tori Stafford saw her charges upgraded to first degree murder Thursday]“
May 31, 2009:
- “Suspect in bludgeoning slaying was on probation”
- “York U. student’s body pulled from Lake Ontario”
- “OPP [Ontario Provincial Police] officer charged with breach of trust”
April 17, 2010:
- “Complaints overwhemlm human rights watchdog”
- “Yonge St. [main commercial thoroughfare in the city] remains closed after wall collapses”
- “Belleville police pull woman’s remains out of Moira River”
- “Suspect and child in custody after morning attack”
- “OPP [Ontario Provincial Police] union wants to know why cocaine charge dropped [against husband of politician]“
- “Suspect sought in elevator fire”
- “Pickering man stabbed in chest during domestic dispute”
About the Author
Alvin Starkman received his Masters in Social Anthropology in 1978. After teaching for a few years he attended Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto, thereafter embarking upon a career as a litigator until 2004. Alvin now resides in Oaxaca, where he writes, leads small group tours to the villages, markets, ruins and other sites, is a consultant to film production companies, and operates Casa Machaya Oaxaca Bed & Breakfast. ( http://www.oaxacadream.com ) .
Puerto Vallarta The Safest Place to be.
|
|
First Alert 3035DF Digital Locking Steel Security Box, 0.27 Cubic Foot, Black/Silver $41.99 Note: Products are not available for Hawaii and Alaska States…. |
|
|
First Alert 2037F Fire and Water File Chest, 0.62 Cubic Foot, Gray $55.95 This UL classified First Alert media protection chest tested to withstand an external temperature up to 1550 degrees for 1/2 hour and independently verified to protect electronic media, such as memory sticks, CD’s, DVD’s and external hard drives. Waterproof even when fully submerged. Key Protector Chest Features: Interior Dimensions(HxWxD): 10.25 in. x 12.17 in. x 8.58 in. Stores standar… |
|
|
First Alert 3040DF Digital Large Security Box, Black/Silver $53.99 Honeywell Security Lock Box with Digital Keypad. Lock it up… from important documents to your prized autographed baseball to your laptop, with the Honeywell Security Lock Box. And while you get BIG peace of mind, thieves just find one aggravating obstacle after another. 48″ security cable. State-of-the-art digital keypad. Double-steel wall construction. Plus, fire-retardant insulation provides a… |
|
|
Passion of the Christ: Songs (Original Songs Inspired by the Film) $16.93 … |
|
|
The Lost Soul $15.00 This CD features six new original works, two of them instrumentals, three traditional songs, and one borrowed tune. 1. Two Doves (Rathje) 5:232. Been All Around This World (trad. arr. Rathje) 3:123. Finn MacCool (Rathje) 3:534. The Lost Soul (trad. arr. Rathje) 2:545. Witch of the Westmereland (Fisher arr. Rathje) 4:146. Dobrology (Rathje) 2:547. Trout (Rathje) 2:408. Temperance Re… |
|
|
Family $18.49 … |
|
|
Charlie Rose – ‘What Just Happened?’ / Religulous (October 13, 2008) $24.95 A conversation about the film ‘What Just Happened?’ with Robert De Niro, Barry Levinson and Art Linson. || A conversation about the film Religulous with Bill Maher and Larry Charles.This product is manufactured on demand using DVD-R recordable media. Amazon.com’s standard return policy will apply…. |
|
|
Keyword Optimization – Complete Guide to Choosing Profitable Keywords for Your Website $14.95 Keyword research and optimization are one of the most important aspects in search engine optimization and rankings. One of the most common mistakes people make when creating a website or putting up an online business is believing they already know what keywords customers are using to find them. If you are not targeting the specific keywords your customers are searching for online, they will NEVER … |
|
|
Quality Pay-Per-Click Traffic Video Series (2008, DVD) $49.99 The DVD includes the following videos: 1 – Understanding Quality Clicks Over Quantity Focusing on clicks that convert is more important than just the concept of getting a high CTR (Click Through Rate). The problem most beginners face is they are taught to use a keyword tool and just start adding tons and tons of keywords into the Adwords keyword list and Walla, some magical conversions will hap… |
|
|
Ohio State Buckeyes Ladies Logo Hair Scrunchie $8.95 Ladies, pull your hair back and show your Buckeye team spirit with this team logo scrunchie!… |
|
|
Bulbrite 1004 Miniature $3.99 0.94A 12.8V B6 D.C. BAYONET Base Miniature Light Bulb… |
|
|
EIKO KPR102 – 2.4V .7A/B3-1/2 SC Mini Flange Base Miniature $4.98 … |
|
|
First Alert 1.2 Cu. Ft. Theft Digital Safe $138.99 This First Alert 1.21 cubic foot safe is constructed of heavy gauge welded steel and is equipped with 2 live door bolts, pry-resistant heavy duty steel concealed hinges, a fully carpeted interior, and a removable/adjustable shelf. Key/Digital Safe Features: Programmable digital lock with override key. Pry-resistant concealed hinges. 2 locking door bolts. Fully carpeted interior. Interior Dimens… |
|
|
Case-mate Armor Protective Film Case for 15 -Inch Apple Macbook Pro (Clear ) $44.99 Case-mate’s Clear Armor for the MacBook Pro 15″ works like an invisible force field protecting your MacBook Pro 15″ from the world. Show off your MacBook Pro 15″‘s inherent beauty with the most technically advanced transparent protective film, Clear Armor. With Clear Armor, Case-mate is the Clear leader in device protection.Installation is easy. Simply remove the film from the backing, spray it wi… |
|
|
Alfa AIP-W505 802.11n/b/g Wireless Broadband Router & Access Point with 4 LAN ports – Wireless-N WiFi WISP, Bridge, AP Router – Advanced Security Futures and Supports URL & Keyword Filtering $49.99 AIP-W505 PCB is the 1 x 10/100Mbps WAN + 4 x 10/100Mbps LAN Ports, 802.11n AP/Router that provide up to 150Mbps high speed throughput. W505 PCB is suitable for WISP applications such as AP/Router mode, WISP mode, WDS Bridge Mode, Wireless Bridge Mode and Hybrid Mode; it’s easy to management by user friendly web-based interfaceSpecifications:ManagementWeb-base management interfaceRemote managementS… |
|
|
Samsung UN46C6300 46-Inch 1080p 120 Hz LED HDTV (Black) $1,699.99 The Samsung LED 6300: LED picture quality meets Auto Motion Plus 120HzTM Clear Motion Rate technology, with gorgeous results. The 6300′s LED Ultra Clear Panel absorbs ambient light and virtually eliminates reflections, for a more comfortable viewing environment. It’s beautiful form and function, complementing the most stylish of décor…. |
|
|
Samsung UN55C6500 55-Inch 1080p 120 Hz LED HDTV (Black) $2,799.99 What do you get when you combine Internet@TV with 120Hz Clear Motion Rate technology? The Samsung LED 6500. Get the best of the web, right on your HDTV, with downloadable and customizable widgets – and coming soon, Samsung apps. Connect to friends, share pictures, shop online and more. Samsung’s 120Hz Clear Motion Rate technology delivers smooth, natural action in every scene. Samsung LED backligh… |
|
|
Samsung UN55C6300 55-Inch 1080p 120 Hz LED HDTV (Black) $2,499.99 The Samsung LED 6300 HDTV: LED picture quality meets Auto Motion Plus 120HzTM Clear Motion Rate technology, with gorgeous results. The 6300′s LED Ultra Clear Panel absorbs ambient light and virtually eliminates reflections, for a more comfortable viewing environment. It’s beautiful form and function, complementing the most stylish of décor…. |
|
|
Hanes Men’s Classic Basic Crew, Three Pack $16.00 Hanes Classics are constructed with very soft ring-spun cotton for added softness and resiliency…. |
|
|
Lilyette Women’s Microfiber Minimizer Bra #428 $32.00 Our Lilyette® Microfiber and Lace Minimizer® Bra offers you the very best in beauty and comfort! * Beautiful and comfortable styling * Luxuriously soft fabric* Gorgeous lace details* Smooth under clothes* Guaranteed comfort* Minimizes size – not shapeFabric content: Top Cup: 91% Nylon, 9% ElastaneBottom Cup: 100% NylonBack: 89% Nylon, 1… |
|
|
Flexees Women’s Fat Free Dressing Tank Top $38.00 Our Flexees® Fat Free Dressing® Tank Top secretly slims, shapes, and smoothes your body. You will feel comfortable all day long, while looking slimmer and trimmer! * Smoothes and shapes midsection* Tummy control* Longer in length so there is no rolling* Eliminates bulges* Great layering piece for today’s fashions* Meant to be seen* Firm control* Soft and comfo… |
|
|
Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society $9.90 Now revised to include new words and updated essays, Keywords focuses on the sociology of language, demonstrating how the key words we use to understand our society take on new meanings and how these changes reflect the political bent and values of society…. |
|
|
The DAM Book: Digital Asset Management for Photographers $31.00 One of the main concerns for digital photographers today is asset management: how to file, find, protect, and re-use their photos. The best solutions can be found in The DAM Book, our bestselling guide to managing digital images efficiently and effectively.Anyone who shoots, scans, or stores digital photographs is practicing digital asset management (DAM), but few people do it in a way that makes … |
|
|
YouTube and Video Marketing: An Hour a Day $14.68 A complete, task-based guide to developing, implementing, and tracking a video marketing strategy Online video marketing is crucial in today’s marketplace. This guide teaches you proven, practical guidelines for developing and implementing video marketing for your organization. If you’re a marketer, advertising professional, consultant, or small business owner, here’s a relevant guid… |
|
|
Green Toys Sand Play Set $12.94 Kids will ‘dig’ building castles and hunting for buried treasure with the environmentally friendly Sand Play Set from Green ToysTM. Made of recycled plastic, this classic 4-piece collection of tools consists of a bucket, sand castle mold, shovel and rake. Made in the U.S.A from recycled plastic milk containers, which helps save energy, reduces landfill waste, and lowers greenhouse gas emissions, a… |
|
|
Alex 36 X 36 Vinyl Padded Playmat $13.20 All roads lead to fun with this take-along play mat that folds into a toy bag. Open it up anywhere – when you’re finished, pack up the toys and you’re on your way| Open mat measures a generous 36″ x 36″ of prime playing real estate…. |
|
|
Alex Toys Draw like A Pro $30.00 A fun and easy way to draw…just turn down the lights, switch on the projector, insert a preprinted slide and trace away| Comes with 124 slides, 6 markers, 10 sheets of paper, and a flip book…. |
|
|
Sirius SL-EX1 Stiletto Executive Speaker System $149.99 SIRIUS SLEX1 SIRIUS(TM) STILLETTO EXECUTIVE SYSTEM DESKTOP AUDIO SYSTEM FOR THE STILLETO FAMILY; 10W PER CHANNEL;HIGH-QUALITY, 2-WAY SPEAKER SYSTEM; BASS ENHANCEMENT TECHNOLOGY FOR DEEPER LISTENING; HEADPHONE JACK;DESK OR WALL MOUNTABLE; AUX IN;INCLUDES EXECUTIVE SYSTEM, WEATHERPROOF INDOOR/OUTDOOR ANTENNA, AC ADAPTER, REMOTE & WALL MOUNT BRACKET SIRIUS(TM) STILLETTO EXECUTIVE SYSTEM… |
|
|
FCS Premium TAIL GATE Surfboard Pad $27.98 These pads help to secure your boards when they extend past your tail gate or trunk. Easy design allows for quick and simple attachment in seconds…. |
|
|
Electric Volt Black Web Belt $28.00 Jump start your look with this Volt web belt by Electric!… |
